Here’s one of history’s great brain teasers, inspired by a game show. Behind one of three doors is a new car. Behind the other two are goats.
Pick a door: Choose one of three doors to guess where the car is.
Host reveals a goat: The host, who knows where the car is, opens a different door to show a goat.
Stay or switch: Choose whether to stick with your original door or switch to the remaining unopened door.
This was the situation that contestants on the TV game show “Let’s Make a Deal,” hosted by Monty Hall, often found themselves in. How did you do?
If you stuck with your original choice, you probably lost more often than you won — statistically, if you stayed put exclusively, you would win just 33 percent of the time. But if you always switched your choice, you would win 67 percent of the time.
That doesn’t make sense, does it? After the first reveal, you have two doors, so you should have a 50-50 chance. Right? But you don’t. The host hasn’t randomly eliminated a door; he has deliberately revealed a goat, using his knowledge of where the car is. Your original door still has a one-in-three chance of hiding the car, while switching gives you a two-in-three chance of winning.
Steve Selvin, who taught biostatistics at the University of California, Berkeley, wrote about this in letters to the journal The American Statistician in 1975. He called it the Monty Hall Problem.
Want to give it another shot?
Dr. Selvin died on Sept. 30 in Oakland, Calif., at 85. His daughter, Liz Selvin, said the death, in a care facility, was from complications of dementia. Along with his daughter, he is survived by his wife, Nancy, and two grandsons.
A longtime professor at Berkeley and Johns Hopkins, Dr. Selvin wrote some 250 papers on biostatistics and epidemiology and 10 books, including “The Joy of Statistics” (2019). He considered his authorship of the Monty Hall letters to be a footnote, and was always a little embarrassed that he was best known for what he called a “trivial problem.”
Dr. Selvin was born on July 4, 1941, in San Francisco and raised in Berkeley. His father, David, was a historian and journalist, and his mother, Susan (Small) Selvin, managed the home. He graduated from the University of California, Riverside, with a degree in mathematics in 1965, and received his doctorate in biostatistics from Berkeley in 1970.
After graduation, he worked for two years at the Birth Defects Institute at the New York State Department of Health in Albany, before joining the Berkeley faculty.
In 1990, the Monty Hall Problem found an audience far beyond academic journals when Marilyn vos Savant (who once had the highest intelligence quotient recorded by the Guinness Book of Records) explained it in her column in Parade magazine.
Chaos ensued. Nearly 10,000 people wrote letters — many saying she was wrong, and some tinged with sexism. Even some noted mathematicians protested. But Ms. vos Savant held her ground, responding with the results of computer simulations that showed she was right, regardless of what might have made intuitive sense.
Dr. Selvin’s name was largely absent from the debate. It wasn’t until the Monty Hall Problem came up on NPR’s “Car Talk” in 1997 that he stepped forward to take credit. The hosts, Tom and Ray Magliozzi, were M.I.T. graduates who featured brain teasers — “puzzlers” — on each show. After they featured the problem in one episode, they received so many angry responses that they got Dr. Selvin’s permission to post an excerpt from his original letters on the “Car Talk” website.
As a show of thanks, they offered to send him a T-shirt.
Produced by Antonio de Luca.
