The Sun Bulletin
No Result
View All Result
Monday, November 16, 2026
  • Login
  • Home
  • World
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Economy
  • Tech
  • Lifestyle
  • Entertainment
  • Trending
Advertisement
The Sun Bulletin
  • Home
  • World
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Economy
  • Tech
  • Lifestyle
  • Entertainment
  • Trending
No Result
View All Result
The Sun Bulletin
No Result
View All Result

At a Roman Palazzo, a U.S. Cultural Agency Defends the Western Tradition

by TSB Report
November 16, 2026
in Trending
Reading Time: 6 mins read
At a Roman Palazzo, a U.S. Cultural Agency Defends the Western Tradition
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Last week, a group of Italian and American academics, political figures and diplomats gathered in a palazzo in Rome. Over two days, they discussed democracy, education, civic virtue and — perhaps unsurprising given the place and current moment — the specter of civilizational decline.

Brian Burch, the U.S. ambassador to the Holy See, wryly recounted to the group how he had gotten calls since the midterm elections from friends worried that “we are in the days of the fall of Rome.” He reassured them that a two-year Congress “is a very short barbarian invasion.”

Still, Burch said, the West is at risk — and not just from its enemies.

“Decline is rarely imposed from the outside,” Burch said. Rather, “it is chosen, one comfortable compromise at a time.”

The conference was organized by the National Endowment for the Humanities, which since President Trump’s return to office has moved to align itself with White House priorities. Those include the staunch defense of Western civilization, which the administration has made a theme of both cultural and foreign policy.

The gathering, which the endowment has not publicized, was titled “Classical Foundations and Moral Authority.” It brought together prominent Italians with nearly a dozen Anglophone academics largely drawn from the ranks of conservative critics of universities, modern secular liberal democracy or both.

American speakers included Patrick Deneen, a political theorist at the University of Notre Dame and the author of the book “Why Liberalism Failed”; R.R. Reno, the editor of the conservative religious journal First Things; and James Hankins, a former Harvard professor who last year wrote a widely discussed essay accusing that university of abandoning the teaching of Western history.

Also on the bill was John O’Sullivan, the British president of the Danube Institute, a Budapest think tank closely aligned with Victor Orban, the former authoritarian prime minister of Hungary. Following Orban’s defeat, the institute recently created an offshoot in the United States dedicated to uniting Europe and America against “malignant ideologies from woke progressivism to radical Islamism.”

The panels, which were recorded and posted on an Italian government website, touched on education, artificial intelligence, law and global affairs. Across the two days, there were frequent warnings that Western democracies were coming unmoored from their moral and cultural underpinnings.

“The Western intellectual tradition forms the bedrock of our democratic institutions, our artistic achievements and our shared cultural heritage,” Michael McDonald, the endowment’s chair, said in his opening remarks. “Yet we may,” he said, “be losing it.”

The endowment did not respond to requests for comment about the conference. But its broad themes reflect continuing shifts at the agency, the nation’s largest public funder of the humanities.

Over the past year, it has directed a significant chunk of its $207 million annual budget to university-based Western civilization and civic thought centers, which are promoted by conservatives as a corrective to the liberal tilt of academia. It recently announced a new program of direct grants to public, private and religious high schools that teach a classical humanities curriculum.

No specific policies or programs came out of the Rome gathering. Instead, the discussion, which frequently circled back to the role of religion in a well-ordered society, kept to a philosophical cast.

On the opening panel, called “Rome and the Foundations of Civil Order,” Marcello Pera, a philosopher and former president of the Italian senate known for his close intellectual friendship with Pope Benedict XVI, described what he said was an instability at the heart of modern liberal democracy.

The liberal state, Pera said, “has conquered the West.” But its emphasis on individualism, and its neglect of the West’s Christian roots, has left it vulnerable.

“How can a society of individuals, each free to pursue their own conception of the good or happiness, remain stable or cohesive?” he asked. “How can the state itself avoid disintegration?”

Speaking on the same panel, Burch, who was a longtime conservative political activist before becoming ambassador in 2025, paraphrased a recent comment by Bishop Robert Barron, a prominent conservative bishop from Minnesota: “We cannot speak coherently about freedom and rights without speaking about God.”

The importance of religion to American democracy was echoed by several other speakers. Reno, whose journal, First Things, recently received a $2 million grant from the endowment, praised a law recently enacted in Texas mandating the teaching of the Bible, which he called “the fountain of our humanistic culture.”

But when it came to the teaching of the broader Western tradition, there were disagreements, including on how to define it. Is the Western tradition an unending argument, with all perspectives equally valid? Or a set of truths to be transmitted?

Deneen, the Notre Dame scholar, hailed the spread of university civic thought centers and the growth of K-12 classical schools. But he called such efforts “insufficiently ambitious.”

Too often, Deneen said, they justify themselves as bringing “viewpoint diversity,” which risks reducing the Western classics to “one minor note in a what is otherwise a dominant massive orchestra of modernist relativism.”

“Most people who say they want to teach the Western tradition don’t want our students to come away raving Communist lunatics,” he said, “but actually want them in some way, shape or form to have a certain set of beliefs.” The challenge, he said, was doing that in a way that doesn’t “stunt their intellectual growth.”

Hankins, who now teaches at the Hamilton School for Classical and Civic Education at the University of Florida, said the most important part of teaching was instilling “intellectual honesty,” including about one’s own mistakes.

“Even if you walk away from Princeton or Harvard or Yale with socialist ideas, which I consider to be simply false,” he said, “reason will get a second chance. Truth will get a second chance.”

But some saw more dire risks in failing to teach the Western tradition. O’Sullivan, of the Danube Institute, traced the recent Paris riots to the French system, which he said, quoting the political theorist Chantal Delsol, has produced “an immense group of illiterates.” It’s no wonder, he said, that they want to “burn down not only their schools” but also the town hall.

At the closing session, McDonald announced there would be a follow-up conference next year in Athens. When it comes to renewing the cultural foundations of the West, one panelist said, “the hour is late” and the problem urgent.

“Let’s try to be more urgent in Athens,” McDonald quipped.

Josephine de La Bruyère contributed reporting.

The Sun Bulletin

© 2025 The Sun Bulletin or its affiliated companies.

Navigate Site

  • About
  • Advertise
  •  Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Contact

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • World
  • Economy
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Tech
  • Trending

© 2025 The Sun Bulletin or its affiliated companies.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In